A Hygienist Had Covid. Shouldn’t My Dentist Have Told Me?

The Ethicist replies.

I was planning to make an appointment with a hygienist working under my dentist and was told by a third party that one of the hygienists had contracted Covid, been treated and was back to work. I am 69, and my nephew died of Covid last May. Four other relatives contracted the virus and recovered. I am nervous about the pandemic.

I requested not to be treated by that hygienist and received this email in response: "To protect the privacy of our staff, just as we do for our patients, we cannot confirm or deny if someone has recovered from the coronavirus. This would be a violation of HIPAA. Your request to not be seen by someone who tested Covid-19 positive was not appropriate, as C.D.C. guidelines state that after 14 days of quarantine, individuals are safe to go out in public. In addition, our clinicians wear appropriate P.P.E. for treatment (including N95 masks, face shields, gowns, gloves), and our office has implemented additional infection-control measures. We monitor for symptoms, take temperatures and measure oxygen saturation daily for everyone that comes into our suite. If this policy makes you uncomfortable, our office may not be a good fit for you."


I have a problem with putting the privacy of an employee ahead of the concerns of a patient. I also thought that HIPAA applied only to disclosures by a doctor about their patients. Am I out of line to make this request? Should a doctor or dentist tell patients if a staff member has had the virus so that the patient can make an informed decision about treatment?

If you've found this newsletter helpful, please consider subscribing to The New York Times — with this special offer. Your support makes our work possible.


Article Image

Sarah Caron for The New York Times

The City Losing Its Children to H.I.V.

A pediatric outbreak in a remote city in Pakistan shows the urgency of global health after Covid.

By Helen Ouyang and Sarah Caron

Article Image

Marta Blue for The New York Times

I Spent My Life Consenting to Touch I Didn't Want

A year of isolation made me consider all the casual, unwanted touch women endure — and why it's so hard to refuse it.

By Melissa Febos

Article Image

Philip Montgomery for The New York Times

Philip Roth Was His Own Favorite Subject. What's Left for a Biographer?

One of the great chroniclers of America's literary lives takes on the author who fought to control his own story.

By Mark Oppenheimer

Article Image

Mamadi Doumbouya for The New York Times


Sen. Mazie Hirono Wonders How Some Republicans Live With Themselves

"When they vote en masse to screw people over, it's hard to be all warm and fuzzy — and I'm not a warm and fuzzy person to begin with."

By David Marchese


Stay in touch:

Follow us on Twitter (@NYTmag) or check us out on Instagram.

Appreciated this email? Forward it to a friend and help us grow.

Loved a story? Hated it? Write us a letter at magazine@nytimes.com.

Did a friend forward this to you? Sign up here to get the magazine newsletter.

Listen to narrated versions of our articles every week. Download Audm for iPhone or Android.

Need help? Review our newsletter help page or contact us for assistance.

You received this email because you signed up for The New York Times Magazine from The New York Times.

To stop receiving these emails, unsubscribe or manage your email preferences.

Subscribe to The Times

Connect with us on:


Change Your EmailPrivacy PolicyContact UsCalifornia Notices

LiveIntent LogoAdChoices Logo

The New York Times Company. 620 Eighth Avenue New York, NY 10018


Posts les plus consultés de ce blog

Chris Ramsey can take the heat, but what would relegation for QPR mean for black managers in the Premier League?

How a team of innovators overcame the odds to create water from thin air

Britain's health service uses long Twitter thread to explain why it needs more black people to donate blood