ESG, a Ratings Agency, and Utah

ESG, a variant of "socially responsible" investment, is a discipline — too kind a word, really — under which potential (or actual) ...

BY ANDREW STUTTAFORD Image April 23, 2022

ESG, a Ratings Agency, and Utah

ESG, a variant of "socially responsible" investment, is a discipline — too kind a word, really — under which potential (or actual) portfolio companies are measured against environmental, social, or governance criteria designed, to no small extent, to support the pretense that the subjective is objective. And it is a pretense made all the worse by the manner in which ESG is being used to further a political agenda without the inconvenience of asking voters what they think. ESG is also a good and sometimes extremely profitable business — an invitation to rent-seeking, which has been eagerly accepted by any number of financial businesses, lawyers, accountancy firms, "consultants," and the like. To help understand why ESG has taken off so quickly, just look at the flourishing ecosystem that it has spawned.

There's a long, long way to go, but there are some signs of a pushback.


Utah's governor and its federal lawmakers are objecting to S&P Global's move to publish ESG scores for U.S. states, calling it an undue politicization of the ratings process.

In a letter sent to the firm on Thursday, the politicians — all Republicans — lay out a lengthy rebuke of S&P's move to release environmental, social and governance assessments, or a so-called ESG score. Despite Utah's results falling in line with many other states, the officials argue S&P should focus strictly on financial fundamentals . . .

S&P's ESG indicators include categories like human rights, social integration, low-carbon strategies, climate measures and sustainable finance.

The ratings agencies have, if nothing else, a keen nose for a money-making business, and that, plus in all probability, a leftwards drift within S&P (as in so many parts of today's capitalist system, from corporations ...   READ MORE





Andrew Stuttaford

Twitter/Musk: Saying No Is Now a Little Harder

Elon Musk hints at a tender ...

Dominic Pino

On Ocean Shipping, Environmentalists Leave No Viable Path Open

The radical environmentalist movement’s ultimate enemy is economic ...

Dominic Pino

Environmentalists Want to Slow Down Ocean Shipping Forever

Slow steaming reduces carbon emissions, but making ocean shipping less attractive could do more harm than ...

Joel Zinberg

Breathing Easier: End of the Mask Mandate?

Everyone but the bureaucrats seems happy it's likely ...

Samuel Gregg

Get Ready: Fighting Inflation Is Hard, Messy, and There Will Be Casualties

Purging excessive inflation from the economy is worth the price. That price, however, is ...

Andrew Stuttaford

Twitter/Musk: Investment Managers and Other People's Money

Managers of non-ESG funds should stick to the task set for them by their clients and not try to decide what is ...



The Case for Nationalism: How It Made Us Powerful, United, and Free

By Richard Lowry

“Makes an original and compelling case for nationalism . . . A fascinating, erudite—and much-needed—defense of a hallowed idea unfairly under current attack.” — Victor Davis Hanson



Learn more about RevenueStripe...
national review

Follow Us & Share

19 West 44th Street, Suite 1701, New York, NY, 10036, USA
Your Preferences | Unsubscribe | Privacy
View this e-mail in your browser.


Posts les plus consultés de ce blog

Chris Ramsey can take the heat, but what would relegation for QPR mean for black managers in the Premier League?

House Of Style! The House Lannister ‘Game of Thrones’ x adidas UltraBOOST